how to deal with microaggressions from patientshow to deal with microaggressions from patients

2016 national healthcare quality and disparities report. First, they completed the Inclusion of the Other in the Self (IOS) scale, a well-validated, single-item, pictorial measure of relational closeness [81, 82] which has been used to assess closeness in interracial contexts [83] and between patients and providers [84]. Personal Soc Psychol Bull. Williams MC. For WAI: Bond, the interaction was significant (p=.01, 2=.46), with White Intervention participants demonstrating a significant and large improvement from pre-intervention to post-intervention (p<.001, d=1.78) and White Control participants demonstrating no change (p=.706, d=0.12). Feeling (mis) understood and intergroup friendships in interracial interactions. For example, our measure of attitudes towards minorities, which is a composite that encapsulates attitudes towards a variety of marginalized identities, showed a large and significant change for POC intervention participants. J Pers Soc Psychol. Abstract Microaggressions and expressions of overt discrimination negatively affect the experience of medical trainees at all levels. But how to deal with microaggressions? Microaggressions, first coined by Pierce [28], are most often defined as brief, everyday, intentional or unintentional verbal and non-verbal behavioral expressions that communicate hostile, derogatory, or negative racial slights and insults to the oppressed target person or group [29]. How to deal with microaggression in healthcare - RNnetwork See Fig. Wherever you go, there you are: mindfulness meditation in everyday life. At the conceptual level, although the IPM likely is the most well-studied social psychological model of how close, intimate relationships develop in dyads, to our knowledge the current report is the first application of key premises of this model in the context of provider-patient interracial relationships. Clin Psychol Rev. Article Thus, sample size was determined based on availability. In addition to overt expressions of racism, so-called microaggressions recognize more subtle expressions of bias. Cookies policy. All participants were required to conduct a 10-min primary care encounter with each patient. Physician racial bias and word use during racially discordant medical interactions. Springer Nature. Freeman L, Stewart H. Microaggressions in clinical medicine. An important strength is that changes in participant behavior, across multiple measures, were observed by independent coders, as actual behavior change in medical provider-patient interactions is the ultimate intervention goal. With respect to self-reported outcomes, the intervention providers themselves, compared to control providers, reported improved explicit attitudes toward ethnic and racial minorities and perceptions of improved working alliances and closeness with the specific post-intervention Black standardized patients with whom they interacted. 2016;57(2):16883. 2010;27(1):7190. In the current intervention, after an introductory didactic on racism and bias in medical care [40], rather than directly trying to reduce or suppress interracial anxieties and stereotypes that may arise in racially charged interactions, providers were taught mindfulness and acceptance skills to become more aware of these processes while reducing their functional impact on behavior. For acting as an ally, no significant effects were found (p=.235, 2=.06). People who engage. Reinforcement matters: A preliminary, laboratory-based component-process analysis of Functional Analytic Psychotherapys model of social connection. In exploratory analyses, we split the data by provider race and re-ran outcome analyses for the 13 White participants and the 12 participants who self-identified as Black, Asian, and other, who we refer to as participants of color (POC). Racial bias in pain assessment and treatment recommendations, and false beliefs about biological differences between Blacks and Whites. This paper presents a pilot randomized trial of an innovative clinical workshop that employed a theoretical model from social and contextual behavioral sciences. Mallinckrodt B, Miles JR, Bhaskar T, Chery N, Choi G, Sung MR. [60]). Maddox KB. Differences in physicians verbal and nonverbal communication with Black and White patients at the end of life. Kanter JW, Tsai M, Holman G, Koerner K. Preliminary data from a randomized pilot study of web-based functional analytic psychotherapy therapist training. Fam Syst Heal. Separate intent from impact. Ann Intern Med. Burgess DJ, Warren J, Phelan S, Dovidio J, van Ryn M. Stereotype threat and health disparities: What medical educators and future physicians need to know. 9 As many microaggressions stem from unconscious, learned ideology, they provide an . DCR, JWK, AMK, and MDC helped with interpreting the data. No significant effects were found for WAI-bond (p=.398, 2=.07) or interaction closeness (p=.054, 2=.32), although for interaction closeness in follow-up tests POC Intervention participants demonstrated a significant and large improvement from pre-intervention to post-intervention (p=.027, d=2.08) and POC Control participants demonstrated no change (p=.530, d=0.20). New York: Hachette Books; 2009. Pers Relatsh. What to know about racial microaggressions - Medical News Today A microaggression can be . Maisel NC, Gable SL, Strachman A. We conducted a pilot randomized controlled trial of the interventions effects on provider responsiveness and emotional rapport building behavior in simulated interracial patient encounters, in which standardized Black patients specifically disclosed racially charged information and presented in ways likely to trigger negative stereotypes and microaggressive responses in the provider. Detailed examples of listening to a client of color who has experienced a microaggression, supporting a client of color who experienced a microaggression, and processing . Patient Educ Couns. 2007;22(6):8827. Psychologists are teaching health care teams to identify and address Patient Educ Couns. 2010;13(3):32944. All authors read, offered suggestions to, and approved the final manuscript. Likewise, acceptance was defined as actively contacting psychological experiences directly, fully, and without needless defense ([38], p. 1163). Addressing microaggressions in racially charged patient-provider interactions: a pilot randomized trial. By Tyrone Fleurizard Phil Goodman -- a pseudonym -- has been teaching the psychology of prejudice for almost a decade. Finally, we note that the use of standardized patients is a strength and a limitation. Psychotherapy. Questions 1 and 2 showed severe range restriction (11 and 1% yes responses, respectively) and were not analyzed. Smedley BD, Stith AY, Alan R. Unequal treatment: Confronting racial and ethnic disparities in health care. Although the Intervention participants did demonstrate a significant and large improvement from pre-intervention to post-intervention (p=.004, d=1.57), Control participants evidenced a small and non-significant improvement (p=.376, d=.33). J Gen Intern Med. Our preliminary evidence suggests that, with additional evaluation, this intervention strategy could be effective for addressing disparities in patient care that have downstream effects on patient health outcomes. Clin Psychol Rev. The training protocol represented two potentially significant innovations over current mainstream anti-bias trainings. The effect of patient race and socio-economic status on physicians perceptions of patients. HLMB and DMM helped with coordinating participants, and HLMB helped implement the workshop. J Exp Soc Psychol. How Should Organizations Respond to Racism Against Health Care Workers Intervention from an allyfor example, when a White man addresses a racial microaggressioncan be powerful (Xie, T., " Responding to Microaggressions: Evaluation of Bystander Intervention Strategies ," 2019). Soc Sci Med. For the 12 participants of color (Table8), all but one of the effects were in the same direction as the larger set of effects but were largely non-significant. Thus it may be suggested that it had the hypothesized impact on provider empathy. Here's the link to the article: "Twelve tips for responding to microaggressions and overt discrimination: When the patient offends the learner" by Daniel Wheeler et . All randomized participants completed the study fully. Part of J Med Signals Sensors. For each standardized patient, the racial challenge instructions were scripted, but otherwise standardized patients were not scripted; they adhered to detailed case descriptions, including specific information about their condition and responses to likely questions from the provider. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2013;103(1):506. Such responses are experienced as microaggressions by many Black patients. Meta-analytic tests of three mediators. Acceptance and commitment therapy, relational frame theory, and the third wave of behavioral and cognitive therapies. Teaching cultural-competence. Personal Soc Psychol Rev. 2019;45(1):4578. Clinicians implicit ethnic/racial bias and perceptions of care among Black and Latino patients. Developing a comprehensive scale to assess college multicultural programming. Saghaei M. An overview of randomization and minimization programs for randomized clinical trials. Although emotional rapport and responsiveness are not often the focus of bias-reduction interventions, they have demonstrated relationships to patients trust in and feeling respected by their doctors, visit satisfaction, and experiences of patient-centered care [10, 13, 14, 18], which are thought of as key mediators of a fundamental pathway through which provider implicit biases affect racial health disparities in both quality and outcomes of medical care [86, 87]. Greenwald AG, McGhee DE, Schwartz JLK. Boston: Porter Sargent; 1970. p. 26582. J Gen Intern Med. 1992;63(4):596612. Psychol Rec. Kennedy Inst of Ethics J. The former demonstrated poor internal consistency (=0.45) and was not included in analyses. Richeson JA, Shelton JN. Regarding the sample composition, the intervention was designed to target normative social psychological processes of bias that are conclusively operative for most White individuals, regardless of professional orientation, and thus are likely expressed across many medical contexts [88,89,90], and there is no reason to believe that the current sample is unique in its susceptibility to bias or responsiveness to the intervention. For the White participants (Table7), the observer-rated outcomes all remained significant. Evidence is accumulating that brief mindfulness skills trainingswhich may include psycho-education about mindfulness, secular meditative practice to improve mindful awareness of ongoing thoughts and feelings (included biased thoughts and feelings), and group interactionsare effective at reducing bias in healthcare professionals [39]. Next, you must be aware of your surroundings and limits. These exercises were modified from exercises previously used to train therapists in responsiveness in FAP trainings (e.g. Fairburn CG, Cooper Z. Therapist competence, therapy quality, and therapist training. For primary analyses, repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) tests were used to assess patterns of change from T1/T2 to T3 by condition. Microaggression coupled with implicit bias (unconscious prejudice in favor or against one person or group) can be psychologically damaging to the targeted community. Psychother Psychosom. 2011;1(1):5561. Shelton JN, West TV, Trail TE. Race and shared decision-making: Perspectives of African-Americans with diabetes. Regarding sample size, our confidence in the robustness of our results is bolstered by the fact that results are consistent across multiple measures, including results obtained from the participants themselves and two sets of blind, independent behavioral coders. Kevin Nadal: Microaggressions are defined as the everyday, subtle, intentional and oftentimes unintentional interactions or behaviors that. What are microaggressions? 1989;36(2):22333. Questions 3 and 4 were dummy coded as no=0 and yes=1 and averaged across the two patient interactions at each time point. Gchter S, Starmer C, Tufano F. Measuring the closeness of relationships: A comprehensive evaluation of the Inclusion of the Other in the Self scale. Behav Res Ther. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. Therapy Tamika Lewis April 18, 2022 It's no secret that we still live in a white male-dominated society where members of minority groups suffer through offensive comments and behavior (microaggressions) regarding their race, gender, sexuality, religion, and the like. That said, the current sample size and limitations prevent the drawing of definitive conclusions. 2010;25 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):16977. 2006;90(5):75183. 13 A health care setting rife with microaggressions (ie, subtle slights and insults that serve to demean, marginalize, or otherize 14) generates a profound sense of personal and professional invalidation among health care workers . 2009;76(2):33043. Microaggressions also impact patient care as they can influence decisions of medical professionals toward a person or group of people. Gr Process Intergr Relations. 6 Steps to Managing Microaggression in a Healthcare Workplace Curr Dir Psychol Sci. 2017;58:14156. The associations of clinicians implicit attitudes about race with medical visit communication and patient ratings of interpersonal care. Am J Public Health. The Oxford Handbook of Close Relationships. Confronting Racism: The problem and the response. Reis HT, Clark MS. Responsiveness. For attitudes towards minorities, a significant interaction was found (p=.002, 2=.36), with Intervention participants demonstrating a significant and large improvement from pre-intervention to post-intervention (p=.001, d=1.37) and Control participants demonstrating a moderate and non-significant improvement (p=.200, d=0.15). 2017;32(4):4018. JWK drafted the manuscript, with input from DCR and KEM. 3) Would you recommend that a Black friend with the same problem as this patient see this doctor over any other doctor? 2014;6(2):181200. Microaggressions happen all the time. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. Kanter JW, Williams MT, Kuczynski AM, Manbeck KE, Debreaux M, Rosen DC. For responsiveness to racial challenges, a significant interaction was found (p=.016, 2=.23), with Intervention participants demonstrating a significant and large improvement from pre-intervention to post-intervention (p=.005, d=1.78) and Control participants demonstrating no change (p=.942, d=0.03). Eliminating Race-Based Mental Health Disparities. The remainder were mixed race (Asian and White-20%; Black and White-4%), Asian (12%), Latino (8%), and Black (4%). 2004;18(4):58999. It is likely also important to examine the effects of the intervention on implicit bias; findings that the intervention does not change implicit bias may indicate that change in implicit bias is not needed for important behavioral outcomes to change. 7,8 Microaggressions are defined as the everyday, subtle, intentional or unintentional behaviors that communicate some sort of bias toward historically marginalized groups. 2004;8(4):383401. Laurenceau JP, Barrett LF, Pietrornonaco PR. Am J Public Health. These exercises specifically were adapted from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) [41], a contextual-behavioral science (CBS) intervention that employs mindfulness and acceptance processes to increase behavioral flexibility which has been shown to be effective across a variety of clinical disorders and treatment contexts [42, 43]. Talaska CA, Fiske ST, Chaiken S. Legitimating racial discrimination: Emotions, not beliefs, best predict discrimination in a meta-analysis. We hypothesized changes on the Empathic Perspective-Taking and Acting as an Ally subscales. Since there is no concrete definition of a microaggression, here are a few: Indirect, often. Horvath AO, Greenberg LS. In: James J, Fong R, Dettlaff A, Rodrigues C, editors. Funders have no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to disseminate the results, or in the preparation of presentations or manuscripts. Participants provided informed consent prior to participation, and the institutional review board approved the study. What are microaggressions, and how do you deal with them? Three Ways Leaders Can Manage Microaggressions At Work - Forbes Thousand Oaks: Sage; 1998. p. 332. The Acting as an Ally subscale demonstrated good internal consistency (s>.70 at both time points) after removing one item from the composite. PLoS One. It is important to include some reflective work around your own internal prejudices in an effort to connect with your empathic response and minimize harmful comments or behaviors. Develop a listening strategy. Dovidio JF, Penner LA, Albrecht TL, Norton WE, Gaertner SL, Shelton J. Sprecher S, Treger S, Wondra JD, Hilaire N, Wallpe K. Taking turns: Reciprocal self-disclosure promotes liking in initial interactions. Terms and Conditions, Thus, in the current intervention, participants engaged in intergroup contact exercises involving reciprocal exchanges of vulnerable self-disclosure and responsiveness. 9 Multiple studies have demonstrated the negative effect of . We note, however, the effect sizes for POC intervention improvements were often still large. Haworth K, Kanter JW, Tsai M, Kuczynski AM, Rae JR, Kohlenberg RJ. How Microaggressions Affect Health at Work | InHerSight By Monica Torres Future research with longer-term follow-up, and development of supplemental follow-up interventions, is recommended. Cross-group friendships and intergroup attitudes: A meta-analytic review. March 3, 2020 For many of us, microaggressions are so commonplace that it seems impossible to tackle them one at a time. All participants completed questionnaires at screening (T1) and baseline (T2) and undertook two baseline standardized patient interactions (T2). Eur J Soc Psychol. Helping the learner to deal with microaggressions in the workplace Beidas RS, Kendall PC. Almond AL. Davies K, Tropp LR, Aron A, Pettigrew TF, Wright SC. Reducing racial health care disparities: A social psychological analysis. Manne S, Rini C, Goldstein L, Ostroff J, Fox K, Grana G. The interpersonal process model of intimacy: The role of self-disclosure, partner disclosure, and partner responsiveness in interactions between breast cancer patients and their partners. Interrupting Microaggressions in Health Care Settings: A Guide for Two of these actors were experienced standardized patients and two were new to this role; all received specific group training and practice with an experienced standardized patient coordinator at a major teaching hospital. 2012;102(5):97987. Art. Module 1: Creating Intercultural Awareness and Understanding Attitudes Microaggressions Beyond ethnocentrism, stereotypes, and biases, we often hear, say, and do things that may carry a negative or derogatory meaning and are therefore understood as microaggressions. Agreement with these items was assessed on 7-point Likert scales ranging from 1 (less close) to 7 (more close). Thomas SL. 2014;1(1):20412. Andrew Limbong: What exactly is a microaggression? The efficacy of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy: An updated systematic review and meta-analysis. Results were split by provider race for additional exploratory moderator analyses, using the same strategy. Microaggression is an unconscious statement or action regarded as discrimination against a marginalized community. For WAI-bond, a significant interaction was found (p=.017, 2=0.22), with Intervention participants demonstrating a significant and large improvement from pre-intervention to post-intervention (p<.001, d=1.15) and Control participants demonstrating a moderate and non-significant improvement (p=.254, d=0.27). That said, our research design tested a multi-component workshop (including didactics, mindfulness training, vulnerable contact, and behavioral rehearsal) and we have no evidence for which components of the workshop were most important in producing observed effects. In: Williams MC, Rosen DC, Kanter JW, editors. Microaggressions - Advancing Intercultural Competence for Global Learners Wright SC, Aron A, McLaughlin-Volpe T, Ropp SA. Price EG, Windish DM, Magaziner J, Cooper LA. Measuring racial microaggression in medical practice. Responsive behaviors in good times and in bad. The second scenario depicted a mid-40s man seeking medication to relieve chronic pain from a work accident, which may challenge rapport by eliciting stereotypes about Black people being drug abusers and medical misconceptions about having higher pain tolerances than Whites [68]. Patient Educ Couns. Summary This review offers education on the correlation of microaggression and unconscious bias to health disparities, provides tools to address microaggressions as a bystander, and outlines processes for . INTRODUCTION The inability to talk about race, racism, and structural racism led to the creation of the term microaggressions. : CD003267. Is racism a fundamental cause of inequalities in health? This small-sample pilot study suggests that interventions that directly intervene to help providers improve responding in these moments by incorporating mindfulness and interracial contact may be beneficial in reducing racial health disparities. Patient-physician communication in the primary care visits of African Americans and Whites with depression. 2013;11(1):4352. There are multiple ways to manage microaggressions in the clinical setting. FAP training emphasizes structured experiential exercises that have been demonstrated to improve clinicians responsiveness in several clinical trials [59,60,61]. Ann Fam Med. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The extended contact effect: Knowledge of cross-group friendships and prejudice. A comprehensive review of research on Functional Analytic Psychotherapy. Addressing microaggressions in racially charged patient-provider The responsiveness finding suggests that the intervention providers were more likely to specifically respond well to the patients in racially charged moments when providers are likely to struggle and engage in behaviors experienced as microaggressive by patients. At T2 and T3, participants completed the 30-item, Everyday Multicultural Competencies/Revised Scale of Ethnocultural Empathy (EMC/RSEE), which has strong evidence for factor structure, reliability and discriminant validity [75]. We expanded the previous 0 code, which originally combined both no responses (e.g., simply ignoring the challenge) and invalidating responses (e.g., defensive or microaggressive responses), into a negative responsiveness dimension and provided anchors and examples for each score, producing a Likert scale from 3 to +3, as shown in Table3. Standardized patients are also important tools for dissemination and implementation research outcome assessments, as the control provided by standardized patients allows for efficient and strategic testing of key skills in response to patient presentations that are unpredictable and variable in actual encounters [95]. Training therapists in evidence-based practice: A critical review of studies from a systems-contextual perspective. J Soc Pers Relat. 2013;7(5):31530. How does intergroup contact reduce prejudice? Paired t-tests for participants within each condition were used to explore significant (p<.05) or approaching significant (p<.10) interactions. Utilizing a randomized controlled parallel trial design, participants were assigned to either the intervention or no-intervention waitlist control condition, blocking by race so that there were equal numbers of Whites in each condition (approximately 60%; see Table1), and equal numbers of non-Whites in each condition (approximately 40%). Ten steps are offered to help therapists respond effectively.